Ann Wallace

When I first walked in the door at Bauer Jewelry Designs, I felt as if I had come home to my personal jewelry store. Kim and Jake are talented, creative, professional, and personable. I had done extensive research online and in person, and this beautiful gem of a store in Middleton surpassed all expectations. Not only did they help me select the perfect set of diamond earrings, they also worked with me to redesign my wedding ring. They listened to my wishes and then used their expertise in design to create a ring that was beyond what I could have imagined. I couldn't be happier with how it turned out. My ring is gorgeous! During this process, Kim and Jake shared their invaluable knowledge about diamond selection and jewelry design. I also brought in some estate jewelry. They offered insightful advice and did beautiful work with those pieces as well. I would highly recommend making an appointment for a jewelry consultation. I will be a customer for life!​

PJ Esser

I came to Bauer after a referral from a close friend. I explained my design, my timeline, and my budget. I also shopped around, going to 3 other local jewelry stores. Bauer was the best value across the board. The experience working with Kim and Jake was incredible. They take so much time to get to know you, to get to know your story, and make sure they are there to do everything along the way. The communication was amazing throughout. And most importantly, the ring is incredible. Truly amazed at how great of job they did.

Absolutely would recommend.

Cade Gentry

Jake is the best in the business. Not only is he competitive with his pricing, but he is a master at his craft. The service is fantastic and the one on one consultation we had was super helpful for us.

Meghann Dawson

Jake and Kim were both amazing to work with! We stopped in there a few months back with some old jewelry and a few thoughts about the possible design for my wedding band and were blown away when we picked it up this week. Jake turned our ideas into a ring that is so much more beautiful than we could have imagined. Throughout the process Kim was so friendly and helpful to work with and helped make the wait seamless. I highly recommend Bauer Jewelry Designs and will definitely be back in the future!

Lucas Nehmer

Kim and Jake were great to work with! They take the time to sit down and customize any type of jewelry you want. They designed a beautiful pendant necklace gift and kept in contact during the entire creation process. If you are looking to create a customized, one of a kind piece of jewelry, I’d highly recommend stopping into Bauer Jewelry.

Nick Zander

I looked all over Madison before coming to Jake and Kim. I felt like every other place was just looking to sell me something, but didn’t really care about what I wanted. I felt they just wanted to know how much I was willing to spend.

Jake and Kim both are great people and I am so happy that I found them. They took the time to get exactly what I wanted, and beat out all of the other competitors prices. The quality of the ring that I purchased from them is second to none. Jake and Kim want to give their customers a superior piece of jewelry for a fair price, while providing outstanding customer service.

James Roloff

Excellent work. Customer service is top notch and the pricing is fair. I highly recommend Bauer for anyone needing custom jewelry work done.


Our mission is to provide true value & create one-a-kind heirloom pieces. 

This year, select a gift that will last a lifetime …

This year, select a gift that will last a lifetime …

Are you planning to pop the big question? …